Signal: Lumber Futures + Homebuilder Confidence
The chasm between this week's signal and noise is about as wide as it can be.
Building permits for new residential projects tumbled to 1.362 million in July—a 45% drop from recent peaks and the lowest level since June 2020. Lumber futures often predict housing market shifts 3-6 months ahead because builders adjust material orders based on project pipelines, not current headlines. After peaking above $1,700 per thousand board feet during the 2021 housing frenzy, prices have collapsed to around $380—a 78% decline that signals builders are scaling back dramatically. When lumber traders see pipeline projects getting canceled or delayed, prices crater ahead of the official housing data.
These housing trends, combined with stock market valuations reminiscent of the dot-com bubble, weak employment data, record consumer debt, and spiraling national debt, paint a concerning economic picture. But don't take my word for it—Jamie Dimon agrees.
Noise: Mortgage rates plunge to nearly year-long lows!
Whoa!
As this was featured prominently across top news networks, there must be something really important here.
In short, mortgage rates reflect anticipated Fed rate cuts of up to 50 basis points (half of one percent).
We've highlighted the silliness of media obsession with Fed decisions in the past, but the drama of what they may or may not do continues to be too enticing to ignore.
My favorite quote from the article:
For homebuyers, the rate drop provides meaningful savings. A borrower purchasing a $450,000 home with a 20% down payment would save approximately $169 per month compared to rates at 7%, reducing their monthly payment from $2,395 to $2,226.
What the data actually shows:
The average mortgage payment for a median-priced home is 38% higher per month than average rent in the largest 50 U.S. metros, creating a national monthly affordability gap of roughly $900.
Consumer debt levels are at all-time highs:
$1.21T in credit card balances
$1.66T in auto loans
$1.64T in student loans
Mortgage rates must fall from current levels (~6.7%) to about 4.4% for buying a home to match rental affordability nationally, with some high-cost cities needing even larger reductions.
80% of aspiring homebuyers say they don't have enough saved for a down payment.
That "meaningful" $169 monthly savings closes just 19% of the national $900 affordability gap—like bailing out a sinking boat with a coffee cup.
While I poke fun at the media hype (and will absolutely continue to do so), there's a sad reality that demands our attention: homeownership, historically a crucial financial stepping stone for American families, remains stubbornly out of reach for many.
Insights: Don’t ask the barber whether you need a haircut.
Warren Buffett shared this witty advice at the 1994 Berkshire shareholder meeting while recounting an acquisition where the seller spent $2 million compiling future projections for the business —and he refused to look at them.
He went on to say: "Don't trust forecasts or projections, especially from someone who has a financial interest in making those projections."
In an era of thought leadership, "authority" marketing, and SMEs (subject matter experts), there are more barbers than ever—people with vested financial interests in whatever "advice" they're dispensing.
My favorite recent example: a private equity group published a book claiming ultimate authority on apartment investing while their assets were underwater and investors were losing millions. It's like Theranos offering a masterclass on medical device innovation.
Reliable data can come from interested parties, but as Charlie Munger warned: If you don't allow for self-serving bias in the conduct of others, you are, again, a fool.
Feynman’s Finance: Bonus Depreciation
Imagine turning a $500,000 property purchase into $64,000 in immediate tax savings. Bonus depreciation—now permanent thanks to recent legislation—lets you deduct improvements in Year 1 instead of waiting decades. It's a wealth acceleration machine that most investors don't understand. [Read the full breakdown →]
The Good Life: John Bogle & Enough
The antidote to troubling economic skies and financial clickbait?
One word - Enough.
That's the principle John Bogle, who founded Vanguard and revolutionized investing by creating the first index fund, captured in this story from his small but powerful book:
At a party given by a billionaire on Shelter Island, Kurt Vonnegut informs his pal, Joseph Heller, that their host, a hedge fund manager, had made more money in a single day than Heller had earned from his wildly popular novel Catch-22 over its whole history.
Heller responds, "Yes, but I have something he will never have... enough."
Bogle is one of my favorite investors, thinkers, and humans. His likeness appears at the top of every newsletter, and his book 'Enough' was the catalyst for starting my company. If you haven't read it, I cannot recommend it strongly enough.
When we define enough for ourselves, we discover the path to both contentment and purpose, and develop an intuitive filter for what deserves our attention.
We’re on a mission to build the most trusted private investing brand in the world at Equity Check.
Find out who are, what we do differently, and why our we only work with the top 1% of private equity sponsors and operators to put investors first. Always.